Sultan Brooch - Sinbad or The Thief of Bagdad?

www.ajraefields.comThis wonderful pot metal brooch was found in a recent estate acquistion.(This is a quick scan) I initially assumed this was the Thief of Bagdad. In doing some research on the internet I am wondering if perhaps it is Sindbad. What do you think?

The line up:

The Thief of Bagdad Inspiration: 

#1 1924 Douglas Fairbanks "The Theif of Bagdad" - Right face, Right stash, but no goatee

#2 1940 Conrad Veidt "Thief of Bagdad"  Very tiny moustache, still no goatee

Next ideas:

Jon Hall of 1942 Arabian Nights has no Facial Hair at all

 1947 Sindbad (Douglas Fairbanks) has a goatee and the right face, I think he is our winner!

http://www.imdb.com/media/rm1486003968/tt003

www.raefielddesigns.com